Defying monoculture

It may surprise many people, but Microsoft is fairly irrelevant to my daily life. I don’t use Microsoft Windows. In fact, no one in my office uses Windows. I don’t use Microsoft Office. At work, I have a Mac; at home, I run Linux.

I don’t use Windows because, frankly, I think it’s a bit shit. It’s clunky and user-hostile. Even when they manage to disguise the mouldering tower of hacks and kludges behind a glossy skin, as in Windows 7 (I have tried the betas) the design decisions seem to be driven more by political and economic concerns than by technical ones. Windows is the Ryugyong Hotel of operating systems: poorly made, expensive, casting a huge shadow, and recently fitted with a new façade of shiny glass.

So today’s release of Windows 7, breathlessly echoed by journalistically subnormal organs like BBC News, is of about as much immediate relevance to me as Kim Jong Il’s entertainment schedule.

Occasionally, though, the Microsoft monoculture rears its ugly head in places where I can’t ignore it. Yesterday, I learned via the cloudsourced blog that some useful information was available free from the Office for National Statistics:

Boundaries for Output Areas (OAs), Lower Layer Super Output Areas (LSOAs), Middle Layer Super Output Areas (MSOAs) and Travel to Work Areas (TTWAs) are available free of charge to all users.

I’d like that. How do I obtain this information?

To obtain boundaries, please complete a boundary request form from the Downloads section and email it to ONS Geography.

What is the request form?

Boundary request form 1.21 Mb Word document

D’oh! ‘Microsoft Word Document’ is a proprietary format, while the ONS is a (non-ministerial) government body. It’s a .gov.uk site. I think it’s inappropriate for the state to provide data only in proprietary formats controlled by a third party. Computing should not require a payment to Microsoft, or any other company, and the state should not assist in reinforcing Microsoft’s monopoly.

Under normal circumstances, I’d install a piece of free software whose programmers have managed to reverse engineer the Word document format, and use that to decipher the file. OpenOffice.org, for example. That would have been easy, but it wouldn’t have been right. I felt that it was important in this case not to acquiesce. I emailed them:

However, my computer is unable to display proprietary Microsoft Word documents, and I am thus unable to fill in the ‘Boundary request form’. Please therefore let me know what additional information you require to fulfil this request.

They probably think I’m an ass. They would be right: I am an ass. But if no one made a fuss, how would they know that their assumption that everyone has Microsoft Office is erroneous?

The ONS replied to my request, asked for my address, and have already despatched the CDs with the data. So I get what I wanted, and I’ve made a point.

There is of course a time and a place for such bolshiness: I don’t expect anyone to start rejecting customer or client documents because they don’t like Microsoft formats. But next time a state body assumes that everyone is uses Microsoft Windows and Office, gently correct them. Maybe at some point they’ll realise.

And if you don’t know why all this matters, read the cautionary tale of South Korea and the SEED cipher:

This nation is also a unique monoculture where 99.9% of all the computer users are on Microsoft Windows. This nation is a place where Apple Macintosh users cannot bank online, make any purchases online, or interact with any of the nation’s e-government sites online.

It’s a hard assumption to undo.

Comments

Skip to the comment form

  1. Dapxin

    Wrote at 2009-10-21 23:35 UTC using Opera 9.80 on Windows XP:

    Interesting post, on its own merits.

    Yes. MS Windows is a bit shit, but you couldn fault the philosophy that built it.

    Maybe it falls short, on the complex road where capitalism, ambition, profit-margin, and everything else, that defines the world-order as is, all converge to drink and whine. Maybe.

    Thing is, It has got us all here. Fact. I speak as someone who has indepth knowledge of both worlds.

    The thing that we know is that, things – good and bad – evolve, they come and go.

    Until they come again, they rule with their imperfections.

    Sum total, I wont be buying Windows 7, but I use Windows XPx64 – It works! It rocks actually.

    I use Linux, It works – for that that you may seek to make it work for. But the attitude that MS represents all that was bad in computing is no less wrong than say the assumption, that Toyota is the face of all that is evil in motoring.

    Its a beautiful world. choice / need / reality / and time.
  2. DigitalDave67

    Wrote at 2009-11-12 01:21 UTC using Firefox 3.0.13 on Windows XP:

    But there’s always the option to read a Word doc with the FREE reader.

Leave a comment

Please read the comment guidelines before posting. Comments are Gravatar-enabled. Your email address will not be published.

To prove that you’re human, type human in the Bot check field.

Trying to post some program output or a long code sample? Please use a paste service and link to it instead.